Access Keys:
Skip to content (Access Key - 0)

How to use an article reporting population-based volume-outcome relationships in surgery

Hong D, Tandan VR, Goldsmith CH, Simunovic M, Evidence-Based Surgery Working Group. Users' guide to the surgical literature: how to use an article reporting population-based volume-outcome relationships in surgery. Can J Surg 2002;45(2):109-15.

Abstract

Relman has defined the current period in North American health care as the “era of assessment and accountability” (EAA). In this era there is a close examination of the actions of health care institutions during the course of patient treatments and the actual patient outcomes that result. In the past, most attention centred on medical efficacy or the development of improved treatments through vehicles such as randomized clinical trials. While recognizing the continued importance of such efforts, the EAA also focuses on effectiveness or what atually happens when treatments are delivered to patients in the real world. A population-based volume-outcomes study is one tool that can be used to gain understanding of the effectiveness of therapies in large groups of patients.

Such studies use large databases and retrospective analyses to explore the relationship between treatment volume of procedures provided by hospitals and patient outcomes.

Most published volume-outcome studies show improved patient outcomes when treatment occurs in higher-volume centres. Such findings often prompt researchers and policymakers to recommend regionalization of the examined procedure into larger-volume hospitals. There are already reports of regionalization of care occurring for certain surgical procedures such as coronary artery bypass surgery, organ transplantation and pancreatic surgery, likely partly due to volume-outcome studies. But like any form of research, poorly designed and reported volume-outcome studies are of little benefit and may even be misleading. Given their potential influence on clinical care, resource allocation and policy decisions, it is imperative that these studies be methodologically sound.

Under what circumstances should you allow the results and conclusions made in a volume-outcomes report to influence your decision-making?

We provide in this article a framework of 3 questions to be considered when critically appraising such studies: Are the results of the study valid? What are the results? And will the results help me care for my patient? The issues are presented primarily for a surgical audience and can be applied to any study using large databases to make inferences about surgical care.

View on PubMed

Download PDF

Peer Review

OrthopaedicsOne Peer Review Workflow is an innovative platform that allows the process of peer review to occur right within an OrthopaedicsOne article in an open, transparent and flexible manner. Learn more

Instructions for Authors

Read our Instructions for Authors to learn about contributing or editing articles on OrthopaedicsOne.

Content Partner

Learn about becoming an OrthopaedicsOne Content Partner.

Academic Resources

Resources on How to use an article reporting population-based volume-outcome relationships in surgery from Pubget.

The license could not be verified: License Certificate has expired!
Orthopaedic Web Links

Internet resources validated by OrthopaedicWebLinks.com

The license could not be verified: License Certificate has expired!
Related Content

Resources on How to use an article reporting population-based volume-outcome relationships in surgery and related topics in OrthopaedicsOne spaces.

Page: How to use an article about a diagnostic test (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Page: How to use an article evaluating surgical interventions (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Page: How to use an article on economic analysis (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Page: How to use an article reporting population-based volume-outcome relationships in surgery (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Page: How to perform a literature search (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Page: How to use a systematic literature review and meta-analysis (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Page: How to assess a randomized controlled trial in surgery (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Page: Self-audit and practice appraisal for surgeons (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Page: How to use a decision analysis (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Page: How to assess an article on health-related quality of life (OrthopaedicsOne Articles)
Showing first 10 of 25 results