|
Year |
2001 |
|---|---|
|
Question Number |
191. |
|
Category |
Select |
Question
A 29year-old man sustained a talar neck fracture with an associated dislocation of the body of the talus from the subtalar and tibiotalar joints. He was treated with immediate open reduction and internal fixation. Twelve weeks later, the fracture has united, and luceny is observed in the superior subchondral bone of the talar body. The next most appropriate step in management should consist of
1. bone grafting of the talar neck and body.
2. application of an ultrasound bone stimulator
3. a brace with calipers
4. MRI to assess body viability
5. protected weight bearing
Figures
Answer (click for answer)
Correct Answer: 5
The young man above sustained a type III fracture of the talar neck. This is important to differentiate because each type has a different prognosis for going on to develop osteonecrosis. The incidence of osteonecrosis is correlated with the degree of displacement created by the injury. Type I fractures have a reported incidence of up to 13%; Type II fracture of 20-50%, and type III fracture of 50-100%. Osteonecrosis can often be excluded at 6-8 weeks post injury if the Hawkins sign is seen on routine radiographs. This is a thin rim of decreased radiodensity in the bone just under the cartilage of the talar dome and is best seen on routine AP or mortise views of the ankle. The lack of a Hawkins sign does not confirm osteonecrosis. As cited in OKU F&A, an MRI study by Thordarson recommended that all type I and type II fractures be allowed protected weightbearing when radiographic evidence of healing at the fracture is present. For type III fractures, it was recommended that MRI scans be done at 8-12 weeks post-injury to assess for osteonecrosis. The answer preferred is #5 because of the Hawkins sign that is present – indicating that the talus has preserved blood supply and is healing, i.e. no osteonecrosis.
Reference: Foot and Ankle OKU, Chapter on Talus fractures
