|
Year |
2002 |
|---|---|
|
Question Number |
146. |
|
Category |
Musculoskeletal Trauma |
Question
A 33-year-old man sustains the closed fractures shown in figures 36a & 36b. The neurologic and vascular status of the extremity are normal. What is the most appropriate initial management.
1- Open reduction and internal fixation of the tibia and the talus
2- Open reduction and internal fixation of the tibia with ankle arthrodesis
3- Open reduction of the tibia and talus and application of a hybrid external fixator
4- Closed reduction and a long leg cast
5- Spanning external fixation of the ankle joint
Figures
Answer (click for answer)
Preferred Response: 5
Pilon or tibial plafond fractures are fractures that injure the articular surface of the distal tibia. They are classified according to the Lauge-Hanson classification system (I: minimally displaced, II: incongruous, III: comminuted). The images included with this question are an AP & lateral of pilon fracture, likely type II or III. These injuries are always surgically treated due to early failures with non-operative treatment. Treatment can be immediate if the fracture is seen within the first 8-12 hours after injury and there has no been much swelling. Otherwise the treatment is to do a spanning external fixator and allow the fracture to "cool" down for 7-14 days to allow the soft tissue swelling to subside. Both of the articles cited carried out immediate ORIF of the fibula with spanning external fixation of the tibia. Their protocols are to ex-fix all pilon fractures and allow them to cool down before they operate even if the patient is immediately brought to the trauma center. The definitive ORIF of the pilon fracture was done in an average of 24 days (1st study) and 12.7 & 14 days (2nd study). The concept behind this form of staged treatment is that due to the high energy nature of the fracture, if adequate fixation can not be achieved early in its course, it is better to stabilize it with an external fixator and allow the soft tissues decrease in swelling and go back at a later time. Operating through the swollen tissue commonly leads to many soft tissue complications that had been seen when these fractures were treated. The first study results: 77% good, 14% fair, 9% poor (Required tibiotalar arthrodesis). They had 86% anatomic reductions and 14% fair reductions. In Rockwood, the author’s preferred treatment is simply to ex-fix the tibia and do ORIF on both bones at once when the swelling has subsided.
The principles of operative treatment of pilon fractures is as follows (From Miller):
1) Restoration of the fibular length with or without fixation.
2) Reconstruction of the articular surface through fracture windows with minimal periosteal stripping.
3) Full-thickness flaps centered over the major fragments with at least 7cm of separation.
4) Bone grafting of the metaphyseal defects
5) Medial stabilization with plating of external fixation
Neither of the articles makes reference to when the patients arrived at the hospital (i.e.->before the 8-12 hour window). In the answers there is no reference to fixation of the fibula at all. Also cast treatment is not a viable option. Ankle arthrodesis is a salvage procedure. Neither of the articles cited does ORIF of the tibia immediately. Therefore, spanning external fixation is correct choice.
Reference: *Patterson MJ, et al. Two-staged delayed ORIF of severe pilon fractures. J Ortho Trauma; 13: 85-91.
*Sirkin M, et al. A staged protocol for soft tissue management in the treatment of complex pilon fracture. J Ortho Trauma; 13:78-84.
*Miller MD. Review of orthopaedics; 3:491-92.
